The twelve omitted letters (shown in parentheses in the list below) spell
A PIECE OF CAKE
The unclued mystery word is ICING

Chronologically (February)
Judy Adamski – Jenison, MI
Max Goodman – Chicago, IL
Al Sanders – Fort Collins, CO
Mike Lessie – Douglassvile, PA
Keith and Elizabeth Falkner – Sarasota, FL
Stan Kurzban – Chappaqua, NY
Gerald Hurtubise – Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Dwight Freund – Sacramento, CA
Ned Robert – Los Gatos, CA
Mary Lyndal Nyberg – Manhattan, KS
Lewis Gee – Poway, CA
Rick Kasten – Alexandria, VA
David Durfee – Petersburgh, NY
Bob Petitto – Carol Stream, IL
Stan Francuz – Forster NSW, Australia
Daniel J. Milton – Vienna, VA
Al Damm – Marshall, WI
Joe Rogers – Old Greenwich, CT
Roy McLeese – Washington, DC
Bob Colonna – Providence, RI
Tony Greanias – Saginaw, MI
Eliot Kieval – NewYork, NY
Daniel A. Sadoff – St. Paul, MN
Joe Schrader – Hillsboro, OR
Carolyn G. & Robert M. Smith – Massena, NY
Caleb Lee – Boston, MA
Matthew Field – London, UK
Carolyn Roosevelt – Cambridge, MA
Jim McNally – Shortsville, NY
Cathy Moran – Studio City, CA
Elaine Woontner – Marion, IN
William Lane – Falmouth, MA
Kris Green – Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Carol Marsh – Greensboro, NC
Patrick D. Phillips – Bainbridge Island, WA
Jonathan Belsky – St Louis, MO
Paul Noack – West Bloomfield, MI
Sue Roberts – Tucson, AZ
Thomas Miller – Hollywood, CA
Kiki Neely – Waban, MA
Michael N. Geselowitz – Cedarhurst, NY
Wayne Jones – Worcester, NY

Alphabetically
Judy Adamski – Jenison, MI
Jonathan Belsky – St Louis, MO
Bob Colonna – Providence, RI
Al Damm – Marshall, WI
David Durfee – Petersburgh, NY
Keith and Elizabeth Falkner – Sarasota, FL
Matthew Field – London, UK
Stan Francuz – Forster NSW, Australia
Dwight Freund – Sacramento, CA
Lewis Gee – Poway, CA
Michael N. Geselowitz – Cedarhurst, NY
Max Goodman – Chicago, IL
Tony Greanias – Saginaw, MI
Kris Green – Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Gerald Hurtubise – Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Wayne Jones – Worcester, NY
Rick Kasten – Alexandria, VA
Eliot Kieval – NewYork, NY
Stan Kurzban – Chappaqua, NY
William Lane – Falmouth, MA
Caleb Lee – Boston, MA
Mike Lessie – Douglassvile, PA
Carol Marsh – Greensboro, NC
Roy McLeese – Washington, DC
Jim McNally – Shortsville, NY
Thomas Miller – Hollywood, CA
Daniel J. Milton – Vienna, VA
Cathy Moran – Studio City, CA
Kiki Neely – Waban, MA
Paul Noack – West Bloomfield, MI
Mary Lyndal Nyberg – Manhattan, KS
Bob Petitto – Carol Stream, IL
Patrick D. Phillips – Bainbridge Island, WA
Ned Robert – Los Gatos, CA
Sue Roberts – Tucson, AZ
Joe Rogers – Old Greenwich, CT
Carolyn Roosevelt – Cambridge, MA
Daniel A. Sadoff – St. Paul, MN
Al Sanders – Fort Collins, CO
Joe Schrader – Hillsboro, OR
Carolyn G. & Robert M. Smith – Massena, NY
Elaine Woontner – Marion, IN